Home Football Manager Guides How to pick your captain

How to pick your captain




At the start of each season you play on Football Manager you receive a message in your inbox about the status of your captain. You then have the choice to either pick a new one or stick with the current selection. You will also get this message when joining a new club, which gives you the opportunity to pick your own if you feel the previous selection wasn’t appropriate.

In this guide we will give you some advice about picking a suitable captain and/or vice-captain.

Responsibilities of a captain

The captain is the leader of your team, the one that will stand tall when he is needed. He will be the leader on the pitch, but he will also affect the team off the pitch. He is your eyes and ears in the team, as he’s a player you can talk to if you need to figure out certain issues within your squad.

It is very important that you and your captain have a good relationship. A bad relationship could end up in you losing the faith of your squad and ultimately you could even lose your job.

Being the captain of your team, you can have a personal chat with him about:

  • His opinion on the current morale in your squad. This could help you to decide whether to hold a team meeting.
  • To talk to a teammate who is unhappy or has some concerns. This option also appears in your inbox when a player wants to have a chat with you.
  • To try and resolve a conflict between teammates that don’t like each other.
  • To help settle new signings at your club.

Read more on:
Morale and motivation
Personalities in Football Manager

phil jagielka captain
Phil Jagielka has good qualities to be the captain of a team

Captains and Dynamics

Introduced in Football Manager 2018: the dynamics system. This system shows the hierarchy of your team and shows you social groups of players that have similar interests or backgrounds (players from the same nation). The dynamics system is key when you want to select a captain.


On the Hierarchy screen you can see that the team is divided in Team Leaders, Highly influential players, Influential players and ‘Other players’. Ideally you want your captain to be in one of the core groups: League leaders or Highly Influential Players.

Hierarchy screen in FM18
Look for players who are labeled as ‘Highly Influential’ or ‘Team Leaders’

Social groups

You should also check out the Social Groups Tab to see in which social group your (possible) captain fits. Is he in one of the larger groups? Good, that means he will have a lot of influence on other players. However, be careful though not to anger your captain if that is the case. If he is part of the largest social group, he could turn that social group against you…

Also, make sure your captain really is a part of a social group and not a player that is not in one of the groups. That could affect a captain’s effectiveness.

What makes a good captain?

When you are picking a new captain, there certain factors you need to consider first:


One of the first things you will look at is a players age. Although there are some examples of young players that wear the band, most captains are at least 25 years of age. Yours should at the very least be one of the more senior players in your squad.


Next to age you will have to look at the attributes of your captain. These determine whether he is capable of leading your team and you should avoid picking a player who lacks these attributes.

The most essential attribute a captain needs is Leadership. Don’t even bother selecting a captain who lacks this attribute. Also look for strong mental attributes that help increase a captain’s influence. Look for high ratings on Determination, Team Work and Work Rate. An attribute that could be useful is Bravery as you do not want a skipper that avoids tackles.

Coach Reports

Have a look at a coach report card before you make a final decision. There are some issues you want to avoid when selecting a captain. One: avoid Injury Prone Players as you don’t want your captain to be sidelined for most part of the season. Two: avoid Selfish players as you don’t want your captain overlook his teammates in attack.


It’s good to pick a player that has a high reputation. You can see a player’s reputation in his profile under the information tab. A player with a high reputation will earn more respect from his teammates.


Replacing your captain

Each year you receive a message in your inbox asking you if you would like to keep or change your captain. You will also receive this message if you join a new club. This is a powerful tool so be careful.

Changing a captain without any reason could result in him being unhappy. This is linked to Dynamics in Football Manager. If your captain is a Team Leader and is part of a Core Social group, players could turn against you if you decide to strip your captain from his armband. If you lose your team’s confidence, you could end up losing your job…

Therefore we advise that if you join a new club (either in the summer or in the middle of the season) not to change your captain. Squad morale is important, especially when a new face is taking over, so if you start off on the wrong foot by coming in and changing the skipper right away, it may go downhill from there.

Pick a vice-captain

A good tip for a slower, gradual replacement of a captain is picking a new vice-captain first. Pick the player you would eventually like to be your team leader. If later on you then decide to sell or demote your current one, the vice-captain will receive the armband automatically.

Keep in mind that if your currently selected captain isn’t selected in the starting lineup for a match, your vice-captain will be chosen to wear the armband for your side (provided the vice-captain has been selected as a starter).

You can also create a list of players that are considered to be stand-ins when your captain and vice-captain are not available. On that list you can pick your future choices, and those will move up automatically if your captain leaves the club or is cut from the team.

pre-purchase Football Manager 2019

Buy Football Manager 2020

Football Manager 20 is available for pre purchase now.
Buy at FMInside and receive a nice 10% discount!



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Buy FM2020

Football Manager 2020 is now available for pre-purchase!

- Advertisment -

Latest players

Lewis Cook

Lewis Cook is one of the ideal Brexit players to keep watching. He plays for Bournemouth, but is keen on moving to one of the club inside the top 6. He will cost you roughly around 45 to 50 million and that is considered a steal for this type of player in the Premier League. He is a very good playmaker and could easily play for one of the big teams in the Premier League.

Lisandro Martinez

Lisandro Martinez is a real catch in Football Manager 2019. The young Argentinian is a talented centre-back and is available for an expected 7M transfer fee. Ideal player to have if you like longer saves and need a good ball playing defender who is able to develop a lot.

Julian Brandt

Julian Brandt has the potential to become one of the elite players in Football Manager 2019. The German winger shows some lethal skills and will have no trouble with playing for the biggest clubs in the world. He has a 70m price tag, which seems a fair price in modern football.

Franck Kessie

If you are looking for a tireless midfielder Franck Kessie could be the ideal player for you. The Ivorian international has all the attributes for a very good ball-winning midfielder. However, it is not possible to sign Kessie in the first two seasons as he is on a loan from Atalanta and will sign on a permanent deal for Milan in the summer of 2019.

Javairo Dilrosun

Former Manchester City left winger Javairo Dilrosun is considered as one of the bigger talents from Holland. He has the potential to become a regular international and is a very handy player if you love a left-footed left winger that will cross in the ball onto your striker. For 22.5 he could be yours, so keep an eye out for him!

Josip Brekalo

Josip Brekalo is a talented player who could develop into an awesome inside forward. The Croatian international is already a first team regular at Wolfsburg and it is expected that he will leave the club on a short term. Keep him on your shortlist as the expected 60m fee could drop after a couple of seasons.

FMI Update 2019/2020

The best transfer update
for Football Manager 2019.
Featuring the 2019/2020 season.

Also interesting

Players with an Expiring contract in FM20

Look for players whose contract will expire in Football Manager 2020. On this list you will see the 60 best players with an expiring deal in FM20.

Football Manager 2020 Release Date

Football Manager 2020 release date has been confirmed by Sports Interactive!

Metallic Logos Megapack 2020

Enhance the realism of Football Manager by downloading the Metallic Logos Megapack. Ten thousands logos for clubs, nations and competitions.